Showing posts with label Scottish referendum. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Scottish referendum. Show all posts

Tuesday, 6 June 2017

#GE2017 Analysis: Are We In For A Youth Turnout Shock?

According to received wisdom the majority of young people in Britain are apathetic.

Based on historic trends, it's difficult to argue against the idea that youth apathy will strike again this Thursday, but in a tumultuous political climate in which received wisdom is being consistently undermined, even this taken-for-granted assumption may be turned on its head.

    


Youth Engagement Has Been In Steady Decline Since 1992 


The downward trend in young people turning out to vote over the previous six general elections is stark.


Data via BBC News.
      

   

But The EU Referendum Has Re-engaged The British Public


Evidence suggests the EU referendum had a hand in raising levels of engagement in the country, with overall turnout rising to 72%, the highest since 1997.

This effect was particularly strong with young voters, with turnout among 18-24 year-olds rising once again to levels not seen since 1992.

Data via Opinium.
 


We Saw A Similar Effect In Scotland After The Indy Ref


Scotland experienced a similar re-engagement in 2014, with an unusually high turnout of 85%.

Turnout dropped in the next two election years, but remained relatively high compared to previous elections to suggest the referendum had a semi-lasting impact on political engagement, although it is now starting to taper off.


Data via BBC News.

     


The Polls Are Wildly Different - Because Pollsters Can't Agree On How Many Young Voters Will Show Up


Pollsters have estimated party support in different ways, with the main discrepancy appearing to lie in how they weigh likely turnout among younger voters.

These modelling differences generate outcomes ranging from a record-breaking Tory landslide to a hung parliament.

Generally speaking, polls predicting a low youth turnout tend to show larger Conservative leads, while polls predicting relatively higher youth turnout shrinks the gap considerably.

Data via listed polling companies.

   

    

... But This Election Campaign Has Excited Young People


This campaign is remarkable not only for the Corbyn surge - something which hasn't been fully explained - but for data showing increased excitement among young people.

Pollsters normally ask people they survey how certain they are to vote (from 1 - 10) in order to measure likely turnout and accurately weigh their raw data samples.

The number of young voters voters answering "10 - absolutely certain to vote" has dramatically risen over the course of the campaign.

Data via listed polling companies. Survation phone age brackets measured 18-34 for April 2017. Survation online age brackets measured 18-34 for April 2017 and June 2017. YouGov age brackets measured 18-24 and 25-49.

 
 

... And This Is Reflected In 2017's Last-Minute Voter Registration Surge


Compared with 2015, an unusually high number of voters registered to vote in the final 21 days before the registration deadline - broadly reflecting the numbers from 2016.


Data via Gov.uk


The number of applications from young people - both as a proportion of all applications and in absolute numbers - was unusually high.


Data via Gov.uk

  
   

What Does All Of This Mean?


Quite possibly, absolutely nothing. Firstly, all of this evidence is circumstantial. Secondly, since polls largely only measure vote share across the country - and not levels of support in individual seats - even a 50:50 split between Labour and the Conservatives could lead to dramatically different seat tallies depending on where the votes fall across the country.

While pollsters have reached a consensus on both the Corbyn surge and increased engagement among under 40s, they have been unable to pin down to what extent this will make a difference.

But based on all the data I would commit to predicting young voters will turn out in 2017 at a significantly higher level than in 2015, broadly reflecting turnout across the age brackets recorded after the EU referendum.


***

Update 25/06/17 - 'The first election since 1992 in which a majority of young people have come out to vote'


Speaking on BBC Radio Five Live in the early hours of Friday morning, Professor Jon Tonge, an academic with Liverpool University, told listeners: "The early data suggests this is the first election since 1992 in which a majority of young people, by which I mean 18-24 year-olds, have come out to vote."


Post-election demographic analysis from pollster Ipsos Mori proves this claim holds true, with 64% of 18-24 year-olds and 64% of 25-34 year-olds having taken part.

Writing on the impact of the shift in demographics, Thiemo Fetzer, assistant professor in economics at the University of Warwick, said: "The results suggest that the major reshuffles in turnout were predominantly due to the (soon to be) grey voters not turning up to vote in 2017 relative to younger voters.

"The Labour party was the big winner, catching almost as significant share of the increase among young voters."

Representatives from both Ipsos Mori and YouGov were approached to comment on the significance of the turnout among young people, and whether this can be sustained in the future, but neither were able to respond to my requests at the time of writing.

Sunday, 15 May 2016

EU Referendum: Neither Side in this Scrappy Debate is Cutting Through

The intensity of the Scottish referendum debate was celebrated for reinvigorating Scottish politics - and we're beginning to see some of the lasting effects.

According to this weekend's ComRes for the Independent/Sunday Mirror, Scottish voters are far more certain to vote than those from any other region.

Respondents were asked how likely they were to vote in a general election on a scale from 0 - 10. Those who answered 10 (absolutely certain to vote) were as follows: England 64%, Scotland 76%, England & Wales 64%, North 66%, Midlands 62%, South 66%. 

Data from late April's Opinium/Observer poll showed similar results, but the question was in reference to the referendum: England 65%, Scotland 70%, Wales 65%.

The EU referendum debate, on the other hand, has so far been a mess - one that has culminated in both sides invoking hyperbolic wartime sentiments; David Cameron by suggesting a Leave vote would lead to World War III, and Boris Johnson by suggesting the European Union is carrying out the aims and objectives of Adolf Hitler, albeit in a less genocidal fashion.

This desperation may be explained by polling data which shows neither side is cutting through, despite the fact this campaign has been running officially for four weeks, unofficially for 12 weeks, and on Question Time for three years.

While polling is neck-and-neck (Remain holds a small lead), a large swathe of the electorate is yet undecided.

***

This is the share of undecided voters over time, based the FT's polling tracker:


The average share of undecided voters from all polls over this period is 14.7%, and the median is 17%. Moreover, there doesn't seem to be any major sign of voters breaking either way.

Although polling from the Scottish referendum reflected similar levels of undecided voters at this late stage of the campaign, the share of don't knows expands when respondents are asked specific questions on the EU's role in our lives; i.e. what both sides' arguments are based on.

The following questions were asked by the ComRes poll I cited earlier.

I would be personally better off if Britain:
Left the EU - 29%
Remained in the EU - 33%
Don't know - 38%

The British government could control Britain's borders if it:
Left the EU - 57%
Remained in the EU - 27%
Don't know - 16%

Britain's national security would be stronger if Britain:
Left the EU - 42%
Remained in the EU - 38%
Don't know - 19%

***

As each week goes by, voters face a fresh bombardment of expert opinions, economic analyses, financial projections, migration studies, security warnings, scare stories and conspiracy theories. This isn't to mention the in-fighting within both camps, and the temporary truces forged between unlikely allies.

In the midst of this haze they may, in the end, ignore the arguments and go with whomever they trust the most. This is what YouGov had in mind when it asked voters for their opinion on the key players in this debate (and for some reason Bill Clinton).




That the politician British voters trust the most on the EU isn't even British speaks volumes. Overall, Leave figurehead Boris Johnson (- 19) is the most trusted, followed by Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn (- 25). David Cameron, who has inserted himself into the heart of the Remain campaign, is the least trusted (- 47). With few exceptions, leading figures from both campaigns have a major trust issue.

Now back again to that ComRes poll, on the question of trust.

Which campaign is "more likely to tell the truth"?
Leave: 39%
Remain: 24%
Don't know: 38%

How these facts plays out over the next few weeks is anyone's guess, although betting markets have consistently given Remain a 60 - 70% chance of winning. Meanwhile, YouGov's 'Lessons from the Scottish Referendum' noted Project Fear only started to hit home in the final two weeks of the campaign, as undecided voters broke towards the status quo.

As things stand, voters don't fully understand the message, and they don't fully trust the messengers. This may not swing voting intention, but I think it may have a dangerous effect on turnout, which in turn could swing the result.

In 2014, 84.6% of the electorate took part in the Scottish referendum to cap off months of enriching debate centred on sovereignty and national identity. But, when it comes to the EU, something in our discourse has gone seriously wrong.

***

Also in the news: Gordon Brown blustered into the Remain campaign last week, hoping for a repeat of his momentous impact in the Scottish referendum. Nobody really paid attention to what he had to say this time, though he did raise a few eyebrows when he challenged Boris Johnson to a one-on-one debate. Normally, that would have been that. But Boris, when quizzed by journalists with Exeter University's XTV, confirmed he'd be game. Surely it would eclipse the dizzying heights of Cameron vs Gove. Could the broadcasters get these teams together to arrange a date?